* 3.1:
[CS] Respect PSR2 4.2
[Form] fix `empty_data` option in expanded `ChoiceType`
[Console] removed unneeded private methods
updated Http-Kernel dependency
[Security] [Guard] Improve comment with working example
sync min email validator version
[TwigBridge] Fix inconsistency in LintCommand help
explicitly forbid e-mail validator 2.0 or higher
Fixed SymfonyQuestionHelper multi-choice with defaults
[DoctrineBridge] Don't use object IDs in DoctrineChoiceLoader when passing a value closure
Differentiate between the first time a progress bar is displayed and subsequent times
finished previous commit
No more exception for malformed input name
fix post_max_size_message translation
[Process] Fix pipes cleaning on Windows
Avoid phpunit 5.4 warnings on getMock
[Form] Add exception to FormRenderer about non-unique block names
[FrameworkBundle] templating can be fully disabled
[Form] Consider a violation even if the form is not submitted
* 3.0:
[CS] Respect PSR2 4.2
[Form] fix `empty_data` option in expanded `ChoiceType`
[Console] removed unneeded private methods
[Security] [Guard] Improve comment with working example
sync min email validator version
[TwigBridge] Fix inconsistency in LintCommand help
explicitly forbid e-mail validator 2.0 or higher
Fixed SymfonyQuestionHelper multi-choice with defaults
[DoctrineBridge] Don't use object IDs in DoctrineChoiceLoader when passing a value closure
Differentiate between the first time a progress bar is displayed and subsequent times
finished previous commit
No more exception for malformed input name
fix post_max_size_message translation
[Process] Fix pipes cleaning on Windows
Avoid phpunit 5.4 warnings on getMock
[Form] Add exception to FormRenderer about non-unique block names
[Form] Consider a violation even if the form is not submitted
* 2.8:
[CS] Respect PSR2 4.2
[Form] fix `empty_data` option in expanded `ChoiceType`
[Console] removed unneeded private methods
[Security] [Guard] Improve comment with working example
sync min email validator version
[TwigBridge] Fix inconsistency in LintCommand help
explicitly forbid e-mail validator 2.0 or higher
Fixed SymfonyQuestionHelper multi-choice with defaults
[DoctrineBridge] Don't use object IDs in DoctrineChoiceLoader when passing a value closure
Differentiate between the first time a progress bar is displayed and subsequent times
finished previous commit
No more exception for malformed input name
fix post_max_size_message translation
[Process] Fix pipes cleaning on Windows
Avoid phpunit 5.4 warnings on getMock
[Form] Add exception to FormRenderer about non-unique block names
[Form] Consider a violation even if the form is not submitted
* 2.7:
[CS] Respect PSR2 4.2
[Form] fix `empty_data` option in expanded `ChoiceType`
[Console] removed unneeded private methods
sync min email validator version
[TwigBridge] Fix inconsistency in LintCommand help
explicitly forbid e-mail validator 2.0 or higher
Fixed SymfonyQuestionHelper multi-choice with defaults
[DoctrineBridge] Don't use object IDs in DoctrineChoiceLoader when passing a value closure
Differentiate between the first time a progress bar is displayed and subsequent times
finished previous commit
No more exception for malformed input name
fix post_max_size_message translation
[Process] Fix pipes cleaning on Windows
Avoid phpunit 5.4 warnings on getMock
[Form] Add exception to FormRenderer about non-unique block names
[Form] Consider a violation even if the form is not submitted
This PR was merged into the 2.7 branch.
Discussion
----------
[Form] Consider a violation even if the form is not submitted
| Q | A
| ------------- | ---
| Branch? | 2.7
| Bug fix? | yes
| New feature? | no
| BC breaks? | yes (only for the behavior)
| Deprecations? | no
| Tests pass? | yes
| Fixed tickets | #11493
| License | MIT
| Doc PR |
Hey!
I'm currently implementing an API using the form component in order to validate the payload sent (in conjonction with the FOSRestBundle). Unfortunatelly, we dig into an issue about the PATCH request which don't map some of our validation rules to the form. Basically, the violations are lost in the middle of the process.
### Use case
We have an entity with the following fields "type", "image" & "video". The field "type"can be either "default", "image" or "video" and then accordingly we use the appropriate field (none for the "default" type, video for the "video" type and image for the "image" type. Then, in our form, we change the validation groups according to our entity type in order to make the "image" field mandatory if the type is "image" and the same for the video field if the type is "video".
### Current behavior
The current behavior (since 2.5) seems to not propages a violation to a form if this form is not submitted but in our use case, changing the field "type" via a PATCH request triggers some new validation which should be reported to end user (inform that a field (video or image) is missing in the PATCH request).
### Expected behavior
The current behavior was introduced in #10567 but IMO, this update is a bug as suggested by @webmozart in https://github.com/symfony/symfony/issues/11493#issuecomment-59549054 Instead, the form component should still map validation errors to the form even if the field was not submitted. If the initial data is not valid, then your initial data was buggy from the beginning but the form should not accept it and instead of silently ignoring the errors, end users should be informed and fix it.
WDYT?
Commits
-------
c483a0f [Form] Consider a violation even if the form is not submitted
* 3.1:
fixed CS
fixed CS
fixed CS
fixed CS
tweaked default CS fixer config
[HttpKernel] Dont close the output stream in debug
move HttpKernel component to require section
Fixed oci and sqlsrv merge queries when emulation is disabled - fixes#17284
[Session] fix PDO transaction aborted under PostgreSQL
[Console] Use InputInterface inherited doc as possible
Mention generating absolute urls in UPGRADE files and CHANGELOG
parse embedded mappings only if value is a string
add docblock type elements to support newly added IteratorAggregate::getIterator PhpStorm support
FormBuilderInterface: fix getForm() return type.
[YAML] Fixed parsing problem with nested DateTime lists
Fixed typo in PHPDoc
* 3.0:
fixed CS
fixed CS
fixed CS
tweaked default CS fixer config
[HttpKernel] Dont close the output stream in debug
move HttpKernel component to require section
Fixed oci and sqlsrv merge queries when emulation is disabled - fixes#17284
[Session] fix PDO transaction aborted under PostgreSQL
[Console] Use InputInterface inherited doc as possible
Mention generating absolute urls in UPGRADE files and CHANGELOG
add docblock type elements to support newly added IteratorAggregate::getIterator PhpStorm support
FormBuilderInterface: fix getForm() return type.
Fixed typo in PHPDoc
* 2.8:
fixed CS
fixed CS
tweaked default CS fixer config
[HttpKernel] Dont close the output stream in debug
move HttpKernel component to require section
Fixed oci and sqlsrv merge queries when emulation is disabled - fixes#17284
[Session] fix PDO transaction aborted under PostgreSQL
[Console] Use InputInterface inherited doc as possible
Mention generating absolute urls in UPGRADE files and CHANGELOG
add docblock type elements to support newly added IteratorAggregate::getIterator PhpStorm support
FormBuilderInterface: fix getForm() return type.
Fixed typo in PHPDoc
* 2.7:
fixed CS
tweaked default CS fixer config
[HttpKernel] Dont close the output stream in debug
move HttpKernel component to require section
Fixed oci and sqlsrv merge queries when emulation is disabled - fixes#17284
[Session] fix PDO transaction aborted under PostgreSQL
[Console] Use InputInterface inherited doc as possible
add docblock type elements to support newly added IteratorAggregate::getIterator PhpStorm support
FormBuilderInterface: fix getForm() return type.
Fixed typo in PHPDoc
* 3.0:
Fix computation of PR diffs for component matrix lines
[console][table] adjust width of colspanned cell.
[BUG] Delete class 'control-group' in bootstrap 3
[2.8] [Form] Modified iterator_to_array's 2nd parameter to false in ViolationMapper
added missing constant in Response
Update HTTP statuses list
[Console][#18619] Prevent fatal error when calling Command#getHelper() without helperSet
added StaticVerionStrategyTest
Add SplFileInfo array doc on Finder iterator methods so that IDE will know what it returns
[2.3] [Form] Modified iterator_to_array's 2nd parameter to false in ViolationMapper
Updated the link to the list of currency codes
Fixed DateTimeInterface comparaison
[console][table] adjust width of colspanned cell.
* 2.8:
Fix computation of PR diffs for component matrix lines
[console][table] adjust width of colspanned cell.
[BUG] Delete class 'control-group' in bootstrap 3
[2.8] [Form] Modified iterator_to_array's 2nd parameter to false in ViolationMapper
added missing constant in Response
Update HTTP statuses list
[Console][#18619] Prevent fatal error when calling Command#getHelper() without helperSet
added StaticVerionStrategyTest
Add SplFileInfo array doc on Finder iterator methods so that IDE will know what it returns
[2.3] [Form] Modified iterator_to_array's 2nd parameter to false in ViolationMapper
Updated the link to the list of currency codes
[console][table] adjust width of colspanned cell.
* 2.7:
Fix computation of PR diffs for component matrix lines
[BUG] Delete class 'control-group' in bootstrap 3
[2.8] [Form] Modified iterator_to_array's 2nd parameter to false in ViolationMapper
* 2.8: (23 commits)
[Filesystem] Better error handling in remove()
[DependencyInjection] Add coverage for invalid Expression in exportParameters
[DependencyInjection] Add coverage for all invalid arguments in exportParameters
anonymous services are always private
[Console] Correct time formatting.
[WebProfilerBundle] Fixed error from unset twig variable
Force profiler toolbar svg display
[DependencyInjection] Resolve aliases before removing abstract services + add tests
Fix Dom Crawler select option with empty value
Remove unnecessary option assignment
fix tests (use non-deprecated options)
remove unused variable
mock the proper method
[PropertyAccess] Fix regression
[HttpFoundation] Improve phpdoc
[Logging] Add support for firefox in ChromePhpHandler
Windows 10 version check in just one line
Detect CLI color support for Windows 10 build 10586
[Security] Fixed SwitchUserListener when exiting an impersonication with AnonymousToken
[EventDispatcher] Try first if the event is Stopped
...
fixes#14712 and #17789.
`ChoiceType` now always use `ChoiceToValueTransformer` or
`ChoicesToValuesTransformer` depending on `multiple` option.
Hence `CheckboxListMapper` and `RadioListMapper` don’t handle
the transformation anymore.
Fixes pre selection of choice with model values such as `null`,
`false` or empty string.
* reference form type by its FQCN instead of its string name
* use the `entry_type` and `entry_options` options instead of the
deprecated `type` and `options` options
* 2.7:
[HttpFoundation] Improve phpdoc
[Logging] Add support for firefox in ChromePhpHandler
Windows 10 version check in just one line
Detect CLI color support for Windows 10 build 10586
[Security] Fixed SwitchUserListener when exiting an impersonication with AnonymousToken
[EventDispatcher] Try first if the event is Stopped
[FrameworkBundle] fixes grammar in container:debug command manual.
[Form] fix "prototype" not required when parent form is not required
* 2.3:
[HttpFoundation] Improve phpdoc
[Logging] Add support for firefox in ChromePhpHandler
[Security] Fixed SwitchUserListener when exiting an impersonication with AnonymousToken
[Form] fix "prototype" not required when parent form is not required
* 2.8:
[Process] Fix stream_select priority when writing to stdin
[Form] NumberToLocalizedStringTransformer should return floats when possible
[Form] remove useless code in ChoiceType
[DependencyInjection] Enabled alias for service_container
Conflicts:
src/Symfony/Component/DependencyInjection/Tests/Compiler/ReplaceAliasByActualDefinitionPassTest.php
src/Symfony/Component/Form/Extension/Core/Type/ChoiceType.php
* 2.7:
[Process] Fix stream_select priority when writing to stdin
[Form] NumberToLocalizedStringTransformer should return floats when possible
[Form] remove useless code in ChoiceType
[DependencyInjection] Enabled alias for service_container
Conflicts:
src/Symfony/Component/Form/Extension/Core/DataTransformer/NumberToLocalizedStringTransformer.php
* 2.3:
[Form] NumberToLocalizedStringTransformer should return floats when possible
[DependencyInjection] Enabled alias for service_container
Conflicts:
src/Symfony/Component/DependencyInjection/Tests/Compiler/ReplaceAliasByActualDefinitionPassTest.php
closes#5906.
The submitted data should always be
transformed back to the model as a string
as NULL in this case could stand for "unset
this value" whereas a string property of a
class could rely on the string type.
Furthermore, this prevents potential issues
with PHP 7 which allows type hinting of
strings in functions.
* check for existance of `setMetadataFactory()` method (this is needed
for tests run with deps=high as the method was removed in Symfony
3.0)
* fix mock testing the `EngineInterface` as the `stream()` method cannot
be mocked when it is does not exist in the mocked interface
* 2.8:
[Validator] Test DNS Url constraints using checkdnsrr() mock
Improved the PHPdoc of FileSystem::copy()
[Validator] Test DNS Email constraints using checkdnsrr() mock
[travis] Run real php subprocesses on hhvm for Process component tests
bug #18161 [Translation] Add support for fuzzy tags in PoFileLoader
[Form] Fix NumberToLocalizedStringTransformer::reverseTransform with big integers
[Form] Fix INT64 cast to float in IntegerType.
[SecurityBundle][PHPDoc] Added method doumentation for SecurityFactoryInterface
FrameworkBundle: Client: getContainer(): fixed phpdoc
[Validator] Updating inaccurate docblock comment
Conflicts:
.travis.yml
* 2.7:
[Validator] Test DNS Url constraints using checkdnsrr() mock
Improved the PHPdoc of FileSystem::copy()
[Validator] Test DNS Email constraints using checkdnsrr() mock
[travis] Run real php subprocesses on hhvm for Process component tests
bug #18161 [Translation] Add support for fuzzy tags in PoFileLoader
[Form] Fix NumberToLocalizedStringTransformer::reverseTransform with big integers
[Form] Fix INT64 cast to float in IntegerType.
[SecurityBundle][PHPDoc] Added method doumentation for SecurityFactoryInterface
FrameworkBundle: Client: getContainer(): fixed phpdoc
[Validator] Updating inaccurate docblock comment
* 2.3:
Improved the PHPdoc of FileSystem::copy()
[Validator] Test DNS Email constraints using checkdnsrr() mock
[travis] Run real php subprocesses on hhvm for Process component tests
bug #18161 [Translation] Add support for fuzzy tags in PoFileLoader
[Form] Fix NumberToLocalizedStringTransformer::reverseTransform with big integers
[Form] Fix INT64 cast to float in IntegerType.
[SecurityBundle][PHPDoc] Added method doumentation for SecurityFactoryInterface
FrameworkBundle: Client: getContainer(): fixed phpdoc
[Validator] Updating inaccurate docblock comment
Conflicts:
.travis.yml
src/Symfony/Component/Validator/Tests/Constraints/EmailValidatorTest.php
* 2.8: (25 commits)
[Console] Fix an autocompletion question helper issue with non-sequentially indexed choices
[Process] Fix pipes handling
Mentioned the deprecation of deep parameters in UPGRADE files
[Filesystem] Fix false positive in ->remove()
[Filesystem] Cleanup/sync with 2.3
[Validator] Fix the locale validator so it treats a locale alias as a valid locale
[HttpFoundation] Fix transient test
[HttpFoundation] Add a dependency on the mbstring polyfill
[2.7] update readme files for new components
add readme files where missing
[2.8] update readme files for new components
fix lowest TwigBridge deps versions
reference form type by name on Symfony 2.7
[EventDispatcher] fix syntax error
Don't use reflections when possible
Don't use reflections when possible
[Form] Update form tests after the ICU data update
[Intl] Update tests and the number formatter to match behaviour of the intl extension
[Intl] Update the ICU data to version 55
[Intl] Fix the update-data.php script in preparation for ICU 5.5
...
Conflicts:
UPGRADE-2.8.md
UPGRADE-3.0.md
src/Symfony/Bridge/Twig/composer.json
src/Symfony/Bundle/FrameworkBundle/DependencyInjection/Compiler/FragmentRendererPass.php
src/Symfony/Component/Console/Helper/DialogHelper.php
src/Symfony/Component/Console/Helper/ProgressHelper.php
src/Symfony/Component/Console/Tests/Helper/LegacyDialogHelperTest.php
src/Symfony/Component/HttpFoundation/composer.json
src/Symfony/Component/Security/Core/README.md
src/Symfony/Component/Security/Csrf/README.md
src/Symfony/Component/Security/Http/README.md
src/Symfony/Component/Validator/Constraints/LocaleValidator.php
* 2.7:
[HttpFoundation] Fix transient test
[HttpFoundation] Add a dependency on the mbstring polyfill
[2.7] update readme files for new components
add readme files where missing
fix lowest TwigBridge deps versions
[EventDispatcher] fix syntax error
Don't use reflections when possible
Don't use reflections when possible
[Form] Update form tests after the ICU data update
[Intl] Update tests and the number formatter to match behaviour of the intl extension
[Intl] Update the ICU data to version 55
[Intl] Fix the update-data.php script in preparation for ICU 5.5
[Process] Fix memory issue when using large input streams
Use constant instead of function call.
fixed test name
automatically generate safe fallback filename
[Console] default to stderr in the console helpers
Conflicts:
composer.json
src/Symfony/Bridge/PhpUnit/README.md
src/Symfony/Bridge/Twig/composer.json
src/Symfony/Component/Console/Helper/DialogHelper.php
src/Symfony/Component/Debug/DebugClassLoader.php
src/Symfony/Component/HttpFoundation/composer.json
src/Symfony/Component/Security/Acl/README.md
src/Symfony/Component/Security/Core/README.md
src/Symfony/Component/Security/Csrf/README.md
src/Symfony/Component/Security/Http/README.md
