diff --git a/plugins/Reply/Reply.php b/plugins/Reply/Reply.php
index 2aca3c3e06..c876eca566 100644
--- a/plugins/Reply/Reply.php
+++ b/plugins/Reply/Reply.php
@@ -116,7 +116,7 @@ class Reply extends Module
                     $data['content'],
                     $data['attachments'],
                     $is_local = true,
-                    $data['reply_to'],
+                    $reply_to,
                     $repeat_of = null
                 );
             } else {